On a recent trip to Niagara Falls we stopped at the Herkimer Hotel. We were a little worried because it is not a "known chain". What a delight to find a privately owned hotel that was excellent. We stayed on the second floor in a newly renovated King interior corridor room. At first it seemed a little weird because there... more

I travel to Herkimer at least a dozen times a year and stay at the "Herkimer Motel". I learned about the Herkimer from a friend who recommended it because my wife is on PD dialysis. We needed a very clean room. The rooms are the cleanest and put many of the larger motel chains to shame. The office staff, the... more

This is a clean comfortable hotel at a reasonable price! The Herkimer Motel is family run and it shows in the property and service they provide. This is an excellent choice when visiting the Herkimer area. Our hotel room and the breakfast room were clean. Staff was pleasant and accommodating. We requested that no spray chemicals be used in our... more

My family and I had planned a 5 day trip to Niagara Falls, Canada from Connecticut and thought we would stay half-way through our trip and visit Herkimer Diamond Mines. I found Herkimer Motel & Suites doing a Google search. Don't hesitate to stay here - we had a brand new room - very nicely decorated with a small refrigerator... more

The hotel is being renovated a bit and was really clean. The price was ok. The train is REALLY close and VERY active. All considering I would stay there again with the exception of this one issue. We booked an adjoining room. It was vital that we stay in connecting rooms. I booked directly with the hotel. We confirmed twice... more

After reading the reviews on tripadvisor, I decided to book 3 nights at this hotel and I am glad I did. The hotel does have a heated swimming pool. The pool was out of commission for 1 day but what really impressed me was the fact that I received a phone call from the hotel a few days before I... more

The Herkimer Motel is an independently owned motel with very clean and updated rooms. (bug free) We have stayed here on two occasions and will be staying here whenever we are in the Herkimer area. The staff is friendly and the continental breakfast is well presented. This place makes an effort to deliver high quality accommodations. It is AAA rated... more

I am always a bit leery of staying in non "name brand" hotels/motels, especially in small towns. This was a thouroughly enjoyable experience though. We chose to stay here mostly because of other reviews on this site. They were accurate. The counter staff was freindly and informative, especially about local eateries. I requested a room away from the railroad tracks... more

Herkimer Motel is conveniently located off the NY State Thruway. I stayed there for 3 nights and found the staff to be friendly and helpful and the rooms clean and welcoming. The rooms have microwaves, mini-fridges, and clean comfortable beds. Other nice commodities are a clean laundry room, an outdoor pool, and an exercise room with treadmills. There is a... more